Logo
Home
>
Investment Strategies
>
Create a bucket strategy for managing retirement withdrawals

Create a bucket strategy for managing retirement withdrawals

05/16/2025
Yago Dias
Create a bucket strategy for managing retirement withdrawals

Planning for retirement income requires both discipline and flexibility. A bucket strategy divides retirement savings into distinct segments that align with different time horizons and risk levels. By matching assets to spending needs, retirees can mitigate sequence of returns risk and maintain confidence through market cycles.

Understanding the Retirement Bucket Strategy

The retirement bucket strategy organizes assets into multiple pools, or “buckets,” each designed for specific withdrawal periods. Most plans use three buckets:

1. Short-term: Funds for immediate expenses over the next one to three years. 2. Intermediate-term: Assets for needs three to seven years out. 3. Long-term: Growth-oriented investments for periods beyond seven years.

This approach provides psychological comfort and financial stability, ensuring that market downturns do not jeopardize essential cash flow.

Benefits of the Bucket Approach

Retirees often face anxiety about depleting savings or selling assets at low prices. The bucket strategy offers:

- Liquidity for near-term spending, avoiding forced sales during dips. - Opportunity for long-term growth, protecting against inflation. - A disciplined framework for systematic withdrawals.

By maintaining cash reserves for immediate needs, retirees can avoid panic moves in market downturns and preserve the integrity of growth assets.

Key Steps to Implement the Strategy

Implementing a bucket plan involves careful planning and periodic maintenance. Follow these core steps:

  • Estimate your annual retirement spending needs, including essentials and discretionary items.
  • Identify guaranteed income sources like Social Security and annuities to fund part of the short-term bucket.
  • Allocate remaining assets: assign cash, fixed income, and growth investments to the three buckets.
  • Establish rules for replenishing the short-term bucket when it dips below a threshold.

Consistent monitoring ensures that each bucket remains aligned with your financial goals and risk tolerance.

Sample Allocation Example

Consider a $3 million portfolio and annual withdrawal target of $150,000. A possible breakdown might be:

In this scenario, $450,000 funds the first three years of spending, another $450,000 covers years four through six, and the remaining $2.1 million stays invested for long-term growth.

Asset Types by Bucket

Selecting the right investments is critical. The short-term bucket demands safety and liquidity, while the long-term bucket seeks growth to outpace inflation.

A balanced intermediate bucket serves as a bridge, earning income without excessive volatility.

Maintaining and Rebalancing Your Buckets

Market fluctuations will naturally shift asset values. To preserve your structure:

- Review allocations at least annually, or when one bucket falls below its target. - Replenish the short-term bucket by selling from the intermediate or long-term pools when conditions are favorable.

Having clear thresholds—for instance, refilling when the short-term bucket drops below 1.5 years of expenses—provides discipline and reduces decision fatigue.

Comparing Withdrawal Methods

Other strategies, such as systematic withdrawals of a fixed percentage, lack the time-horizon segmentation of the bucket approach. While a 4% rule is simple, it may expose retirees to greater volatility and potential income shortfalls during down markets.

The bucket strategy, in contrast, aligns investments with spending needs, offering both growth potential and capital preservation.

Tax Implications and Required Minimum Distributions

Tax planning is essential when managing buckets across account types:

- Tax-deferred accounts (IRAs, 401(k)s) require RMDs beginning at age 73. - Roth IRAs offer tax-free growth and avoid lifetime RMDs. - Coordinate withdrawals among taxable, tax-deferred, and tax-free buckets to optimize your tax bracket.

By drawing strategically from different account types, retirees can minimize lifetime taxes and control their taxable income each year.

Pros and Cons Overview

The bucket strategy holds significant advantages, including reduced stress about market timing and increased spending discipline. However, it also demands ongoing attention to rebalancing rules and spending estimates. Without vigilant management, retirees may either overspend or leave excessive funds idle.

Understanding these trade-offs ensures you implement a plan that matches your comfort level and financial complexity.

Practical Planning Tips and Common Pitfalls

Successful bucket management requires flexibility and regular review. Consider these best practices and watch for common mistakes:

  • Adjust bucket horizons based on changing market conditions or personal health and lifestyle shifts.
  • Perform a formal review at least once a year, rebalancing to target allocations.
  • Maintain clear records or separate accounts for each bucket to simplify tracking.
  • Forgetting to revisit spending needs, leading to underfunded buckets.
  • Neglecting tax coordination, resulting in higher overall tax bills.
  • Allowing emotion to drive withdrawals during market swings.

By staying proactive and partnering with a trusted advisor if needed, you can secure a steady income stream and enjoy a more confident retirement journey.

Yago Dias

About the Author: Yago Dias

Yago Dias